Skip to content

Lightning decisions

Lightning prediction vs detection: why your weather app warns you too late (and what to use instead)

Jason Deese, Founder & CEO

Reviewed by the Flash Meteorology Desk against the Accuracy Method page · Published · Updated · 9 min read

Long-exposure lightning bolt over a dark rural horizon in navy and indigo with one warm gold streak — Flash Weather article cover for Lightning prediction vs detection

Up to 60 minutes ahead · 1×1 km cell · Refreshed every 2 minutes

In this article · 8 sections

Most weather apps forward alerts from a lightning detection network. That network is excellent at one thing: telling you, within seconds, that a cloud-to-ground strike has just happened and where. The word that matters is "happened".

The alert you got was for a strike that already happened

The first strike of a storm cell is on the ground before the first alert leaves the server. If that strike is inside your radius, the notification is a report, not a warning — and the people on the field learned about it from the sky. Apps that "warn" from detection apply a distance rule to those reports: a strike inside the radius you chose triggers the push. That works when a storm approaches from a distance. It fails when the cell builds overhead.

That is the gap this article is about: the difference between being told a strike occurred and being told one is coming. The rest of it explains what the three technologies you will be sold actually measure, how much lead time each can give, and how to check a vendor's accuracy claim before you sign anything.

How detection networks work

A detection network — NLDN is the reference in the United States, and the ground truth we score against — listens for the electromagnetic signature of a discharge. Several stations time-stamp the same pulse; the differences in arrival time fix the location. The result is a precise map of where a storm has been, updated as each strike lands.

Because the network reports what has already discharged, its lead time for the first strike at your site is zero. Its real value is in the minutes after: it confirms the storm is active, shows where the cell is tracking, and — through the all-clear rule the NWS still teaches — starts the clock for the all-clear. A detection feed is a superb record. It is not a forecast.

Why electrostatic "prediction" sensors are a different thing

An electric-field mill — the sensor some vendors sell as "prediction" — measures the atmospheric electric field at the point where it is mounted. A rising field means charge is building nearby, and the unit sounds when the field crosses a threshold. It is a real physical measurement, and it can fire before the first strike.

Its limits are physical too. It sees one point. It needs a mast, power, calibration and a clear site. The field can rise without a strike following, which is where its false alarms come from. And it has to be bought, installed and maintained at every site you want covered — for a district with many schools, that is a mast, a calibration schedule and a replacement plan at every one of them.

What AI prediction does

Flash starts from the other end. The prediction engine ingests 30+ integrated data signals — radar, satellite, surface observations, model fields — and distils them into 15+ proprietary prediction products for every 1×1 km cell across the continental U.S. The model re-runs every 2 minutes and outputs, per cell, the likelihood of a strike over the next 60 minutes, with a 5-hour lightning probability alongside. No mast, no site visit: your site is a pin on the map with a radius and a policy.

  • 30+integrated data signals in
  • 15+proprietary prediction products
  • 1×1 kmgrid cell, refreshed every 2 min
  • 60 minstrike-level prediction horizon

Measured against NLDN ground-truth strikes, the one-hour prediction window scores up to 99.6%. How hits, misses and the false-alarm ratio are counted is published on the accuracy method page with the arithmetic behind each one.

A storm shelf cloud rolling over an empty field at dusk before any lightning has struck, the window a prediction fills and a detection network cannot

The hour before

A detection network has nothing to report here yet. A prediction does.

"Detection tells you where lightning has been. Prediction tells you where it is about to be. Only one of those is a decision you can still make."

Jason Deese, Founder & CEO

Detection vs sensor vs prediction

  • Detection network

    Lead time
    None for the first strike; confirms strikes after the fact
    What it measures
    The radio pulse of a discharge that has occurred
    False alarms
    Rare for strike reports; the "warning" is only a radius rule
    Install
    None on site; an app or a feed
  • Electrostatic sensor

    Lead time
    Minutes, at the mounted point, once the field rises
    What it measures
    The local electric field at one point
    False alarms
    The field can rise without a strike; site-dependent
    Install
    Mast, power, calibration — one per site
  • AI prediction (Flash)

    Lead time
    Up to 60 minutes per 1×1 km cell, refreshed every 2 minutes
    What it measures
    30+ integrated data signals distilled into 15+ prediction products per cell
    False alarms
    False-alarm ratio published on the method page, with the arithmetic
    Install
    None; software only, sites live in days

Troon, the Big 12, Syngenta and the NAIA

Troon
Flash is an approved vendor across all 700+ Troon golf properties. The extra minutes are the difference between a horn that clears the back nine in time and a horn that follows the strike.
Big 12
Flash is the official weather safety provider of the Big 12 Conference.
Syngenta
Flash is the API lightning provider for Syngenta.
NAIA
Official Weather Monitoring & Alert System of the NAIA through October 2028.

How to check a vendor's accuracy claim

Every vendor will show you a percentage. Before you accept it, ask the four questions we answer for our own numbers on the accuracy method page.

  1. What is the window? A 60-minute prediction is a different claim from a claim with no stated horizon at all.
  2. What is the ground truth? We score against NLDN strikes. A claim scored against the vendor's own alerts is circular.
  3. What is the period? Ours is stated on the accuracy method page and restated each time the window moves.
  4. What are the misses? Ask for first-strike detection and false-alarm ratio, not just the headline percentage.

Frequently asked

Only if you accept zero lead time on the first strike. The app forwards a detection report and applies a radius; the first strike inside that radius is what triggers it.

Yes. The all-clear clock after the last strike is a return-to-play rule, not a detection rule. Prediction moves the first decision earlier; it does not shorten the all-clear.

No — it uses it. NLDN strikes are the ground truth every prediction is scored against, and confirmed strikes still drive the all-clear timer.

It depends on the storm: the model refreshes every 2 minutes, so the number for your cell updates as the cell develops. The median lead time is published on the accuracy method page.

Jason Deese

Founder & CEO, Flash Weather

Founder of Flash Weather in Canton, Georgia, built to replace the "strike already happened" alert with one you can still act on. Reviewed against the Flash Accuracy Method on 21 Sep 2026.

The Flash Lightning Suite screen showing predicted strike cells and first-strike timing, the product this article describes
Lightning Suite

Live demo · No sensors required for the forecast

See your own sites on the map before the next storm.

We'll load your locations, replay last season's strikes against Flash's predictions, and show you the alert log your safety officer would have received.